YA Graphic Novels/Comics

Author George Takei
-
Publisher : Top Shelf Productions
-
Publication date : July 16, 2019
-
Edition : First Edition
-
Language : English
-
Print length : 208 pages
-
ISBN-10 : 1603094504
-
ISBN-13 : 978-1603094504
-
Item Weight : 1.14 pounds
-
Reading age : 10+ years, from customers
-
Dimensions : 6.63 x 0.65 x 9.06 inches
-
Part of Series : They Called Us Enemy
-
Grade level : 10 - 12
-
Best Sellers Rank: #5,988 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
-
#163 in Memoirs (Books)
Plot Summary
​They Called Us Enemy is a graphic memoir by George Takei that chronicles his childhood in Japanese American internment camps during World War II. The book, which is told through the perspective of an adult Takei at various public events, details his family's forced relocation after the bombing of Pearl Harbor, their experiences behind barbed wire, and his father's enduring faith in democracy. It explores themes of injustice, loyalty, and resilience, and draws parallels between the historical internment and contemporary issues.The story begins just after the bombing of Pearl Harbor, when Executive Order 9066 leads to the forced removal of Japanese Americans from their homes. The Takei family, including young George, is sent to internment camps, first in Arkansas and later in California.The memoir vividly portrays the joys and terrors of growing up under legalized racism, with George experiencing the camps as a strange kind of home while witnessing his parents' hardships and resilience.
About the Author
​​A stunning graphic memoir recounting actor/author/activist George Takei's childhood imprisoned within American concentration camps during World War II. Experience the forces that shaped an American icon and America itself in this gripping tale of courage, country, loyalty, and love.George Takei has captured hearts and minds worldwide with his captivating stage presence and outspoken commitment to equal rights. But long before he braved new frontiers in Star Trek, he woke up as a four-year-old boy to find his own birth country at war with his father's -- and their entire family forced from their home into an uncertain future.
In 1942, at the order of President Franklin D. Roosevelt, every person of Japanese descent on the west coast was rounded up and shipped to one of ten "relocation centers," hundreds or thousands of miles from home, where they would be held for years under armed guard.They Called Us Enemy is Takei's firsthand account of those years behind barbed wire, the joys and terrors of growing up under legalized racism, his mother's hard choices, his father's faith in democracy, and the way those experiences planted the seeds for his astonishing future. What does it mean to be American? Who gets to decide? When the world is against you, what can one person do? To answer these questions, George Takei joins co-writers Justin Eisinger & Steven Scott and artist Harmony Becker for the journey of a lifetime.

Critical Evaluation
​
They Called Us Enemy highlight its success as a powerful and personal account of Japanese American internment, emphasizing its educational value and the way it humanizes historical events for a new generation. Critics praise its emotional depth, which explores the struggle for identity and loyalty, the impact of systemic injustice, and its call to action to prevent future discrimination. Some evaluations also note how the graphic novel's black-and-white palette visually conveys the difficulty of remembering the past. The memoir is a firsthand account of the internment experience, detailing the pain, joy, and reflection of George Takei's childhood. It is considered essential reading for understanding the injustices of Japanese American internment, making a complex historical event accessible and memorable for a broader audience. The book effectively explores themes of identity, loyalty, and the struggle against systemic racism.The use of a black-and-white palette is noted for its symbolic power, representing the haziness of memory and the trauma of the past. The book concludes with a powerful message about remembering history to prevent its repetition, serving as a call to action against injustice.
While some may praise the book's visual style, one evaluation notes a contradiction between the black-and-white palette and the idea of childhood memories being full of color, but ultimately concludes it effectively represents the difficulties of recalling the past. The book's inclusion in a recent ban in Tennessee brings its educational and historical content into the political spotlight, underscoring the ongoing relevance of its themes regarding government overreach and discrimination.
​
Readers Annotation
It examines how the government's actions challenged the family's sense of American identity and loyalty, but ultimately, Takei's father taught him the power of democracy, even if flawed. The memoir vividly portrays the joys and terrors of growing up under legalized racism, with George experiencing the camps as a strange kind of home while witnessing his parents' hardships and resilience.
​
Genre
​Graphic Novel, Autobiography, Comics, Non-fiction comics, Memoir
​
Book Talking Idea
Analyze the cover and discuss what the title, "They Called Us Enemy," implies and who "they" and "us" refer to.
​
Challenge Issues
The challenging issues surrounding They Called Us Enemy include its recent banning in some areas, which has sparked debate about restricting historical content, and the book's difficult themes like the trauma of Japanese American internment, the erosion of civil liberties, and the lingering shame experienced by survivors. The book also faces challenges in its presentation for younger audiences, requiring book talks and context to help students understand the historical significance of the events it portrays.
Book bans, Historical context, Psychological trauma, Shame and silence
Challenge Issue Resources:
-
-
Collection Development Policy
-
FAQs for library employees about answering questions about youth and access to library resources
-
Contact info for ALA Office of Intellectual Freedom (OIF)
-
Active listening skills – library employees will listen and respond without judgment. They will ensure that the complainant is heard and will attempt to respond to the complaint fully. If the complainant is not satisfied, he or she will be directed to fill out and submit a Request for Reconsideration of Library Resources.
-
List of awards and reviews for the materials
-
If available, info on material from https://www.teachingbooks.net
-
Library Bill of Rights on Intellectual Freedom
-
Library Bill of Rights Interpretations (designed by Intellectual Freedom Committee)
-
Journal of Intellectual Freedom and Privacy (JIFP) - includes substantive essays, peer-reviewed articles, book reviews, legal briefs, and opinion pieces.
-
Intellectual Freedom Manual - day-to-day guidance on maintaining free and equal access to information for all people, including:
-
34 ALA policy statements and documents, 17 new or updated for this edition, addressing patron behavior, internet use, copyright, exhibits and use of meeting spaces
-
At-a-glance lists summarizing key issues such as access, challenges and censorship, access by minors to controversial materials, and advocacy
-
Explanations of legal points in clear, easy-to-understand language, alongside case citations
-
Numerous checklists to help readers stay organized
-
-
Request for Reconsideration of Library Resources
-
Guidelines for Reconsideration Committee
-
Process of the reconsideration along with timeline and how the complainant will be informed of the outcome
-
Author Tyler Feder
-
Publisher : Rocky Pond Books
-
Publication date : April 5, 2022
-
Edition : Reprint
-
Language : English
-
Print length : 208 pages
-
ISBN-10 : 0525553037
-
ISBN-13 : 978-0525553038
-
Item Weight : 1.01 pounds
-
Reading age : 12 - 17 years
-
Dimensions : 6 x 0.66 x 9 inches
-
Grade level : 7 - 9
-
Best Sellers Rank: #132,634 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)

Plot Summary
Dancing at the Pity Party is a graphic memoir by Tyler Feder about her experience with grief after her mother died of cancer when Feder was in college. The book chronicles the stages of her mother's illness, death, funeral, and the subsequent decade of grief as she navigates life as a motherless daughter. It blends poignant memories and raw emotion with humor to create a candid and relatable story about loss, highlighting the difficult "firsts" without her mom and the overwhelming nature of grief. The memoir begins as Feder starts her first year of college and her mother is diagnosed with late-stage cancer. Feder returns home to help care for her mother, documenting the process of her illness and death, including family interactions and their responses to the unfolding tragedy. The memoir also touches on Jewish mourning customs, like shiva, and Feder’s own spiritual confusion regarding death.The narrative extends ten years past her mother's death, showing Feder's ongoing struggle with grief, the emotional impact of not being able to share everyday moments with her mom, and the need to create new traditions.
About the Author
​
​Feder is a Chicago-based artist known for work that explores "Big Feelings, feminism, and pop culture". She graduated from Northwestern University and also studied comedy writing at The Second City Training Center, which influences the frank and often humorous tone of her work. Dancing at the Pity Party is her debut solo graphic novel, a raw and honest account of losing her mother to cancer when Feder was in college. She runs an illustration company called Roaring Softly, where she sells prints and illustrations. Feder is also the author and illustrator of the acclaimed picture book Bodies Are Cool. She has done freelance illustration work for notable clients like Netflix, Comedy Central, and ESPN.

Critical Evaluation
The memoir's bracing candor and personal vulnerability. Feder doesn't shy away from the "good, the bad, and the awkward" moments of losing a parent, which creates an intimate and immediate connection with the reader. A major strength highlighted in reviews is the successful integration of humor and "nervous laughter" with a heavy subject. This balance is seen as a realistic portrayal of how people cope with tragedy, allowing for both crying and laughing while reading. The "deceptively simple" and clean line art, with a consistent use of pastel colors, is praised for being accessible to a wide range of readers, including those new to the graphic novel format. The art style lends itself to emotional impact without overwhelming the narrative. The memoir is considered an important resource for teens and young adults (ages 12 and up) who have experienced similar losses, as it makes them feel "heard" and less isolated in their grief. It also educates others on the complexities of the ongoing grieving process. The insights into the practical aspects of death, such as funeral planning and "post-death firsts," as well as its exploration of Jewish cultural traditions surrounding mourning (sitting shiva) and mental health. Witty diagrams, like the "Fun School Tyler" vs. "Grief/Panic Tyler" illustration, are seen as effective storytelling devices.
​
Readers Annotation
​The book uses humor to make the experience accessible, ultimately serving as a cathartic and uplifting tribute to Feder's mother and a comforting guide for others who have experienced loss.
​
Genre
​Graphic novel, Comics, Biography
​
Book Talking Idea
​Ask questions like; have you ever felt like you're the only one going through something difficult? or How do you support a friend who's grieving?
​
Challenge Issues
Misuses of God's name, illustration of a corpse, mild profanity
Challenge Issue Resources:
-
-
Collection Development Policy
-
FAQs for library employees about answering questions about youth and access to library resources
-
Contact info for ALA Office of Intellectual Freedom (OIF)
-
Active listening skills – library employees will listen and respond without judgment. They will ensure that the complainant is heard and will attempt to respond to the complaint fully. If the complainant is not satisfied, he or she will be directed to fill out and submit a Request for Reconsideration of Library Resources.
-
List of awards and reviews for the materials
-
If available, info on material from https://www.teachingbooks.net
-
Library Bill of Rights on Intellectual Freedom
-
Library Bill of Rights Interpretations (designed by Intellectual Freedom Committee)
-
Journal of Intellectual Freedom and Privacy (JIFP) - includes substantive essays, peer-reviewed articles, book reviews, legal briefs, and opinion pieces.
-
Intellectual Freedom Manual - day-to-day guidance on maintaining free and equal access to information for all people, including:
-
34 ALA policy statements and documents, 17 new or updated for this edition, addressing patron behavior, internet use, copyright, exhibits and use of meeting spaces
-
At-a-glance lists summarizing key issues such as access, challenges and censorship, access by minors to controversial materials, and advocacy
-
Explanations of legal points in clear, easy-to-understand language, alongside case citations
-
Numerous checklists to help readers stay organized
-
-
Request for Reconsideration of Library Resources
-
Guidelines for Reconsideration Committee
-
Process of the reconsideration along with timeline and how the complainant will be informed of the outcome
-

Author Maia Kebabe
-
Publisher : Oni Press
-
Publication date : May 28, 2019
-
Edition : 1st
-
Language : English
-
Print length : 240 pages
-
ISBN-10 : 1549304003
-
ISBN-13 : 978-1549304002
-
Item Weight : 1.05 pounds
-
Reading age : 18 years and up
-
Dimensions : 5.75 x 0.7 x 8.25 inches
-
Part of Series : Gender Queer: A Memoir
-
Best Sellers Rank: #51,023 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
Plot Summary
Gender Queer is a graphic novel memoir by Maia Kobabe that follows the author's journey of self-discovery regarding gender identity and sexuality, from childhood through young adulthood. It chronicles their experiences with puberty, friendships, crushes, coming out to family, and finding their non-binary and asexual identity through illustrations and personal anecdotes. The book aims to be a guide and source of affirmation for other queer, trans, and non-binary individuals and their families by exploring feelings of gender dysphoria and euphoria.Kobabe describes feeling different from an early age, a feeling that intensifies during puberty and their first period. They navigate questions about their identity and sexuality, including crushes on both boys and girls, leading to an initial understanding of being bisexual.

About the author
​The author and illustrator of the controversial graphic novel Gender Queer: A Memoir is Maia Kobabe. Kobabe is a nonbinary, queer author and artist who uses e/em/eir pronouns. Kobabe holds an MFA in Comics from the California College of the Arts and worked as a librarian for over a decade before becoming a full-time freelance author and activist. Kobabe has become a prominent voice in the fight against book banning, using eir platform to advocate for the freedom to read and the importance of diverse literature for queer and nonbinary youth
Critical Evaluation
​
The book is a crucial resource to many readers, particularly LGBTQ+ youth, that helps them feel less alone in their experiences and provides language for their feelings. The memoir is an insightful and accessible guide for those who want to understand the nonbinary experience, gender dysphoria, and asexuality, helping readers interrogate their own biases and become better allies. Kobabe's storytelling is honest, vulnerable, and matter-of-fact. The illustrations, using soft pastels and earth tones, are viewed as skillful and effective in bringing a deeply personal story to life. The core message of the book is a powerful affirmation of self-love, the fluidity of identity, and the importance of supportive family and community in one's journey to self-identity.
The book has become a flashpoint in U.S. culture wars, leading to widespread efforts to ban it from school and public libraries. Many will be upset with the handful of illustrations that depict sexual acts, masturbation, and menstrual blood, leading some conservative groups and politicians to label the book "obscene" and "pornographic". The content is deemed to not be suitable for minors, even though age recommendations from various sources (publishers, the author, the American Library Association) typically range from ages 14-18 and up.Challenges to the book are often linked to a broader political backlash against LGBTQ+ rights and education in schools, with critics sometimes conflating the book's presence with "grooming" children.
​
Readers Annotation
​A guide for those who feel similarly, providing a narrative and illustrative explanation of what it's like to be non-binary and asexual.
​
Genre
​Graphic novel. Autobiography, Biography. Comics
​
​Book talking Ideas
Discuss the significance of finding the right language and pronouns (e/em/eir) for self-expression and the impact this has on eir life and relationships.
Challenge Issues
Sexually Explicit Content. Explicit illustrations. LGBTQ+ content
Challenge Issue Resources:
-
-
Collection Development Policy
-
FAQs for library employees about answering questions about youth and access to library resources
-
Contact info for ALA Office of Intellectual Freedom (OIF)
-
Active listening skills – library employees will listen and respond without judgment. They will ensure that the complainant is heard and will attempt to respond to the complaint fully. If the complainant is not satisfied, he or she will be directed to fill out and submit a Request for Reconsideration of Library Resources.
-
List of awards and reviews for the materials
-
If available, info on material from https://www.teachingbooks.net
-
Library Bill of Rights on Intellectual Freedom
-
Library Bill of Rights Interpretations (designed by Intellectual Freedom Committee)
-
Journal of Intellectual Freedom and Privacy (JIFP) - includes substantive essays, peer-reviewed articles, book reviews, legal briefs, and opinion pieces.
-
Intellectual Freedom Manual - day-to-day guidance on maintaining free and equal access to information for all people, including:
-
34 ALA policy statements and documents, 17 new or updated for this edition, addressing patron behavior, internet use, copyright, exhibits and use of meeting spaces
-
At-a-glance lists summarizing key issues such as access, challenges and censorship, access by minors to controversial materials, and advocacy
-
Explanations of legal points in clear, easy-to-understand language, alongside case citations
-
Numerous checklists to help readers stay organized
-
-
Request for Reconsideration of Library Resources
-
Guidelines for Reconsideration Committee
-
Process of the reconsideration along with timeline and how the complainant will be informed of the outcome
-

-
Publisher : First Second
-
Publication date : August 18, 2020
-
Edition : Illustrated
-
Language : English
-
Print length : 288 pages
-
ISBN-10 : 1250193532
-
ISBN-13 : 978-1250193537
-
Item Weight : 1.3 pounds
-
Reading age : 12 - 18 years
-
Dimensions : 6.1 x 0.85 x 8.5 inches
-
Grade level : 7 - 9
-
Best Sellers Rank: #109,703 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
Plot Summary
Kiku, a girl growing up in Seattle. During a trip to San Francisco with her mother, though, Kiku experiences a displacement—she is transported back in time and space to her grandmother's time, when her family was taken to a camp for Japanese Americans during the Second World War.
The story begins in 2016, with Kiku, a half-Japanese American teenager, on vacation in San Francisco with her mother. As Kiku waits on a bench in Japantown, where her grandmother's family once lived before their forced removal, she is suddenly and inexplicably transported through time.
These "displacements" continue to occur, eventually leaving Kiku effectively trapped in the 1940s. She finds herself in the same internment camp where her late grandmother, Ernestina, was incarcerated as a young woman. Kiku lives among the internees, experiencing firsthand the harsh realities, injustice, and racism faced by Japanese Americans who were denied their civil liberties.
About the Author
​Hughes is a comics artist and writer based in the Seattle area. She is mixed race and is of Japanese heritage. Her work has been featured in Team Avatar Tales, Short Box #6, the Alloy, Elements and Beyond Anthologies, and others. "Displacement" tells the story of a fictionalized version of Kiku who is taken back in time to various points in her grandmother's life, particularly her time spent at the concentration camp Topaz. Her grandmother died before Kiku was born, and many stories of camp were lost with her. Kiku finds herself trapped in time as well as in camp with her grandmother, and while she learns to live in the harsh conditions, she also learns the stories that were not passed down to her.
​

Critical evaluations
Displacement is a graphic novel for young adults that uses time travel to explore the Japanese American incarceration during World War II and its intergenerational trauma. The book highly relevant and necessary, tying past injustices to contemporary issues of racism and anti-immigration sentiment, particularly during the 2016 US presidential campaign. It can be recommended for educational curriculums (specifically for middle and high school students) as an accessible and powerful introduction to the topic of Japanese American internment, identity, and racist policy. The artwork is effective, using a subdued color palette to add gravity and varied panel sizes to drive the story cinematically. The use of magical realism (time travel) effectively bridges the past and present without detracting from historical accuracy. It explores how survivors often don't talk about their trauma due to shame and how this silence creates a disconnect for later generations, which the book helps reclaim. While it raises important questions about climate refugees, it is limited by its focus on a privileged family. This choice may reach a broader audience but potentially minimizes the disproportionate effect of climate change on marginalized communities. The book has some cliché language and plot conveniences, but it has a harrowing premise and its ability to stick with the reader long after finishing, serving as a potential "prescient warning" of the future.
Lucy Knisley's Displacement (Travelogue Graphic Novel). YA literature handles displacement to help young readers engage with difficult topics, develop empathy, and understand issues of identity and resistance related to socio-political events.
Readers Annotation
Using children's literature with themes of displacement as a pedagogical tool in classrooms, helping children find "anchors" to their own lives and develop critical literacy skills.
Genre
Graphic novel. Comics. Historical Fiction. YA literature
​
Book Talking Ideas
Ask question: "What would you do if you had to leave your home tomorrow, knowing you might never return?"
​
Challenge Issues
​There hasn't been and challenges or banning of the novel.

Author Tony Medina
-
Publisher : Lee & Low Books
-
Publication date : October 10, 2017
-
Edition : Standard Edition
-
Language : English
-
Print length : 176 pages
-
ISBN-10 : 1620142635
-
ISBN-13 : 978-1620142639
-
Item Weight : 12.5 ounces
-
Reading age : 12 - 18 years
-
Dimensions : 6 x 1 x 9 inches
-
Grade level : 6 - 12
-
Best Sellers Rank: #84,441 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
Plot Summary
Fifteen-year-old Alfonso Jones is a typical teenager living in New York City, attending an arts academy, playing the trumpet, and developing a crush on his friend Danetta. He is excited about playing the role of Hamlet in his school's upcoming hip-hop production and thrilled that his wrongfully incarcerated father is soon to be released from prison. While shopping for his first suit with Danetta at a department store, an off-duty white police officer mistakes a clothes hanger in his hand for a gun and shoots him dead. When Alfonso wakes up in the afterlife, he's on a ghost train guided by well-known victims of police shootings, who teach him what he needs to know about this subterranean spiritual world. Meanwhile, Alfonso's family and friends struggle with their grief and seek justice for Alfonso in the streets. From this ethereal perspective, Alfonso is able to see the impact of his death on his family and friends, and he watches as his story becomes a catalyst for protests and the Black Lives Matter movement. The book connects Alfonso's story to the historical context of racial injustice by introducing him to other victims from different eras, like Amadou Diallo, who act as guides on his journey.

About the Author
​Tony Medina, winner of the 2025 Letras Boricuas Fellowship through The Mellon Foundation and Flamboyan Arts Fund, is a poet, graphic novelist, editor, short story writer, and young adult and children’s book author. Born in the South Bronx and raised in the Throgs Neck Housing Projects, Medina earned a BA in English at Baruch College, CUNY, on the GI Bill, and an MA and PhD at Binghamton University, SUNY, where he received the Distinguished Dissertation Award. Medina has published 24 multi genre award-winning books for adults and young readers, the most recent of which are Because the Sky (poetry); Che Che Colé (fiction); Death, With Occasional Smiling (poetry); Thirteen Ways of Looking at a Black Boy(children’s); I Am Alfonso Jones (graphic novel); and Resisting Arrest: Poems to Stretch the Sky (anthology). Medina’s awards and honors include The National Black Writers Conference Nikki Giovanni Award, a New York State Proclamation and State Legislative Resolution, the Paterson Prize for Books for Young People (twice), the Langston Hughes Society Award, the first African Voices Literary Award, the Lee Bennett Hopkins Poetry Award honor, Special Recognition from the Arnold Adoff Poetry Award, and the Firecracker Alternative Book Award from the American Booksellers Association for In Defense of Mumia. His most recent book, Death, With Occasional Smiling (Indolent Books,) was a finalist for both the International Book Award and the Independent Book Award, while his verse memoir, My Old Man Was Always on the Lam, was a finalist for the Paterson Poetry Prize, and the audiobook adaption of his children’s verse biography, I and I, Bob Marley (Live Oak Media), featuring actor Jaime Lincoln Smith, received the 2022 Audie Award in the Young Listeners category. Medina has appeared in several documentaries and CD compilations and has read/performed his work all over the United States, as well as in Germany, France, Poland, the Bahamas, Puerto Rico, and the Netherlands. The first professor of creative writing at Howard University, Medina’s poetry, fiction and essays appears in over 170 journals and anthologies, including Where We Stand: Poems of Black Resistance; The Future of Black: Afrofuturism, Black Comics, and Superhero Poetry; We Rise, We Resist, We Raises Our Voices; Manteca! An Anthology of Afro-Latin@ Poets, and Brown Sugar: A Collection of Erotic Black Fiction, as well as Sheree Renée Thomas’ Dark Matter, Ishmael Reed’s Hollywood Unchained, and Kevin Young’s Library of America anthology, African American Poetry: 250 Years of Struggle & Song, and as an advisory editor for Nikki Giovanni’s Hip Hop Speaks to Children. Medina has also been featured on NBC’s philanthropic reality show, Give, PBS’ White House Chronicle, CBS’ Great Day Washington, SiriusXM’s Kids Place Live, Medgar Evers College’s Writers on Writing, Forbes magazine, and has worked extensively with the non-profit literary organizations Say It Loud, Behind the Book, and Meet the Writers. Medina’s book, Thirteen Ways of Looking at a Black Boy, was featured on Let’s Learn NYC for PBS and his graphic novel was a Barnes & Noble Graphic Novel Best Seller, a finalist for the Excellence in Graphic Literature Award, and was a “Book to Action” feature in the Orange County Public Library System of California, among other honors.
​
Critical Review
I Am Alfonso Jones is a necessary and important read for middle and high school students, serving as a powerful conversation starter about systemic racism and social justice in America. It is an unflinching look at a tragic reality, offering no easy answers but instead encouraging thought, empathy, and action. The integration of Hamlet allusions and historical facts adds layers of depth that make it a rich text for educational settings. The book is widely lauded for tackling the difficult and crucial subject of police violence against Black individuals, a topic that resonates deeply with current social issues. It is a valuable tool for educating young people about the history of police injustice. The book is heart-wrenching, anger inducing, and sometimes painful to read, highlighting its ability to make readers feel the profound grief and injustice faced by victims and their families. Medina integrates real-life victims of police shootings (such as Amadou Diallo and Eleanor Bumpurs) as "ancestors" who guide Alfonso in the afterlife, providing historical context and an "Ancestors Wall" at the end of the book that lists names of victims. This grounds the fictional story in reality and serves as a call to action. Medina's book is detailed and appealing characterizations, which use language natural to teens. Alfonso is depicted as a normal, relatable teenager with dreams of acting and a first love, which makes his tragic death even more impactful.​
A recurring point of critique is the non-linear storytelling. The narrative jumps between Alfonso's past life, his experience in the afterlife on a "ghost train," the aftermath of his death for his family, and scenes from his school's hip-hop version of Hamlet. Some readers found this made the storyline "confusing and hard to follow" at times. Sometimes it felt like the author tried to cover too many interconnected issues (such as the prison industrial complex, media manipulation, and gun control) within one story, which occasionally distracted from the central plot and messages. The black-and-white art style in cool, but additional color could have enhanced certain scenes.
​
​
Readers Annotation
The story shows how the deaths of young people like Alfonso can inspire future generations to take action, fight for change, and carry on their legacy.
​
Genre
YA Literature. Graphic. Comics
​
Book Talk Ideas
What historical connections do Alfonso and his peers make to the crisis of mass incarceration?
Challenge Issues
Themes of Police Brutality and Racial Injustice. Social Justice Issues/ "Woke" content. Critical Race Theory. Controversial Discussions. Negative view of police
​





